William Safire and James Wood are two different people. with different thoughts. different positions. but do hold similar authorship manners. In William Safire’s “A Spirit Reborn” he talks about the Gettysburg Address in comparing to 9/11 and he besides analyzes the Gettysburg Address in more deepness and has a specific intent for composing his article. On the other manus in James Wood’s “Victory Speech” he talks about how President Obama flowed through different things. Wood besides analyzes certain inside informations of Obama’s address. and offers some review. “Now. as so. a national spirit rose from the ashes of destruction” ( Safire 41 ) .
The Gettysburg Address was given after a atrocious incident. with really tragic losingss. By traveling through these destructive events. our state becomes stronger. and more bonded together. After 9/11. the Gettysburg Address was reborn to convey us recollection. togetherness and encouragement through tough times. In his essay. Safire states that 9/11 was “the worst bloodletting on our district since Antietam Creek” ( 41 ) . By conveying back past events such as the conflict of Antietam. Safire likely strikes a batch of strong emotion from his readers by utilizing it in comparing to 9/11.
To recycle a address such as the Gettysburg Address at a clip such as after 9/11 was improbable to be thought of. since they were two different events. 138 old ages apart. In Safire’s article in the New York Times. he analyzes the Gettysburg Address in more item. He talks about how “you will hear the word dedicate five times” ( Safire 42 ) . and what each one of them stand for. For illustration. he says the first two refer to “the nation’s dedication to two ideals mentioned in the Declaration of Independence… ‘Liberty’… ‘that all work forces are created equal” ( Safire 42 ) .
The 3rd is pointed towards a certain approval of the location of the conflict of Gettysburg. and the 4th and 5th dedications are directed back to the ideas of autonomy and that all work forces are created equal. for which the deceased work forces of the conflict fought for. Safire besides notices that “the address is grounded it construct. birth. decease. and rebirth” ( 42 ) . He mentions some specific quotation marks such as “The state was ‘conceived in liberty’… delivered into life – by ‘our fathers” ( Safire 42 ) . He besides brings up decease and re-birth by drawing more quotation marks from Lincoln’s memorable address.
Safire does non desire us to “listen to merely Lincoln’s celebrated words and soothing cadences” ( 43 ) . Alternatively he wants us to retrieve the message Lincoln was giving to us. he wants us to appreciate the asleep and the losing. and wants to remind us that “this generation’s response to the deceases of 1000s of our people leads to ‘a new birth of freedom” ( Safire 43 ) . “First he moved through the people… Then he moved through the country… so he moved through time” ( Wood 611 ) . The intent Wood says for Obama making this ; was “to bind those lesions by adhering us together” ( 611 ) .
By conveying people from different ages. orientation and gender. from different provinces and metropoliss. Obama hopes to convey our state back together as one state. He besides mentions how Ann Nixon Cooper. who is one 100 and six old ages old. had voted utilizing merely a finger. to demo how the times have changed. Wood analyzes some inside informations of Obama’s address. such as how “Yes we can” changed to “Yes we did” and “Yes we may” . Detecting the impact those few words had on the crowd by stating it was “extraordinarily traveling in its sobriety” ( Wood 611 ) .
Wood besides mentions how he added it to past tense. utilizing a note of being unsure. He besides draws attending to Obama’s usage of the word promise. after Obama says “I promise you – we as people will acquire there” in mention to a difficult route to acquire to alter. Wood says the word promise is used in recognition to Martin Luther King’s address from Memphis. King says “and I’ve seen the Promised Land. I may non acquire at that place with you” but Obama knows he will so acquire where we are traveling. In the beginning of Wood’s “Victory Speech” he talks about how “last Tuesday dark was a really good dark for the English language” ( 610 ) .
Since James Wood is a critic. it is merely suiting that he give some feed-back on Barrack Obama’s address. He says that “many of us would hold watched in cryings as President-elect Obama had merely thanked his run staff and shuffled off to bed” ( Wood 610 ) . Wood says that his address was filled with such history and emotion. that if he merely grumbled thanks. American would non be satisfied. In the terminal both Safire and Wood had analyzed two different addresss in deepness. but Safire had a specific intent for making so. to convey emotion. while Wood critiqued. There were a batch of differences. but some similarities. non many. but some.